The Shirley Estate—a behemoth of land, control, and aristocratic tyranny. Stretching across County Monaghan, intertwined with the equally vast Bath Estate, these two properties loomed over the Irish landscape like twin specters of colonial conquest.
According to The Landowners of Ireland, 1878, the biggest landowner in Co. Monaghan in 1876 was Evelyn Philip Shirley, a name that rings with the hollow echoes of wealth built on the backs of tenants. He owned 26,386 acres, valued at a staggering £20,744, all sitting comfortably within the barony of Farney.
Did he rule his estate like a king? No—he was a semi-absentee, showing his face twice a year as if dropping in to inspect his livestock.
Meanwhile, the Marquess of Bath, from his cushioned throne in Longleat, Wiltshire, controlled 22,762 acres in Farney without so much as setting foot on the soil that bore the weight of his fortune. The two men were inheritors of Elizabethan conquest, their estates gifted not by sweat or toil, but by decree—a 1575 grant from Queen Elizabeth I to Walter Devereux, the 1st Earl of Essex.
Land was not earned. It was stolen.
The Gaels Take Back Their Land—For a While
The 2nd and 3rd Earls of Essex (1576-1646)
As fate would have it, these English conquerors did not hold the land uncontested. Robert Devereux, the 2nd Earl of Essex, inherited the estate at just ten years old, his lands placed in the hands of trustees. He grew into Elizabeth’s golden boy, a favorite of the Queen, basking in her affection—until he failed her. His disastrous campaign in Ireland and suspected treason led to his downfall, and in 1600, he was executed, his lands seized by the Crown.
Enter the MacMahons, one of the last Gaelic powerhouses in Monaghan. Ever MacColla MacMahon stormed back into the land of his ancestors, claiming the whole barony of Farney. It was an act of defiance, a declaration that the Irish were not finished. He even had the audacity to ask King James I to legitimize his control over the territory.
And for a brief moment, it worked.
The 1606 land settlements left much of Monaghan in Gaelic hands, a rare win in an era of conquest. But power shifts quickly. By 1646, the 3rd Earl of Essex had died intestate and without heirs, and the estate was cracked in two—half to the Marquess of Hertford, half to Sir Robert Shirley.
The cycle of conquest began again.
A Family Forged in Blood and Politics
Sir Robert Shirley was no better than his predecessors. A staunch Royalist, he met his fate imprisoned in the Tower of London, dying in 1656 for backing the losing side in the English Civil War. His son, Sir Seymour Shirley, inherited the fragmented estate, which continued to be passed through generations of lords, viscounts, and earls, each determined to keep their grip on Farney, Warwickshire, and beyond.
The Shirley-Bath Divide of 1692 was one of power, money, and politics. Robert, Earl Ferrers, inherited one half of the estate, while Thomas Thynne, 1st Viscount Weymouth, got the other—a division that heavily favored Weymouth. But English aristocrats, despite their greed, loved a good show of fair play—so Weymouth compensated the Ferrers line, ensuring no squabbles would spill into polite society.
It was a family affair, stitched together with land deeds, bloodlines, and an unwavering commitment to profit over people.
The Shirley Family’s Strongest Weapon: Absentee Rule
By the 19th century, the Shirleys were absent landlords in all but name. They built a house near Carrickmacross around 1750, but their true home was in Ettington, Warwickshire. It wasn’t until 1826 that Evelyn John Shirley even bothered to construct a proper mansion near Lough Fea—a symbol of power, a monument to a dynasty that had held firm against rebellions, revolutions, and shifting monarchies.
But the real power wasn’t in the hands of the Shirleys.
It belonged to the men who carried out their will.
The Estate Agents: Enforcers of the Shirley Empire
Where there is oppression, there are enforcers. In the Shirley Estate’s history, the agents—the men who collected rent, evicted tenants, and controlled the land—were often just as infamous as their landlords.
Sandy Mitchell: The Tyrant of Farney (1829-1843)
Mitchell was feared, despised, and loathed in equal measure.
- He raised rents by one-third.
- He charged tenants for access to bogland, land that had been free for centuries.
- He enforced Protestant education on Catholic children, banning Catholic teachings in schools.
- He evicted families who resisted.
When Mitchell dropped dead of apoplexy in Monaghan town in 1843, bonfires were lit across Farney. His death was celebrated like a festival—because for the people of Farney, it meant hope.
W.S. Trench: The “Bayonet Collector”
Mitchell’s replacement, William Steuart Trench, was just as ruthless. If Mitchell was a tyrant, Trench was a military strategist, executing landlord law with bayonet precision.
- He pushed “assisted emigration” schemes, forcing Irish families to flee to America and Canada.
- He refused to negotiate rent reductions, even as farmers faced ruin.
- He threatened to collect rent “at the point of a bayonet.”
The tenants fought back. On April 3, 1843, thousands gathered at the rent office in Carrickmacross, demanding to speak to Evelyn John Shirley. But Shirley, hiding in his estate, sent Trench instead.
The crowd did not take it well.
Trench was dragged toward Lough Fea, fearing for his life. It was only the intervention of a local priest that saved him from what would have been justifiable retribution.
Legacy of the Shirleys: A Warning, Not a Celebration
The Shirley Estate, like so many Anglo-Irish landholdings, was built on conquest, control, and suffering. Its history is not one of romantic grandeur, but of survival—not for the landlords, but for the tenants who endured their rule.
Today, remnants of the estate remain. The mansion at Lough Fea still stands, a symbol of a time when land meant power, and power meant holding on until the bitter end.
But the truth cannot be buried.
For the people of Farney, the name Shirley does not inspire nostalgia. It is a name etched into the land—not in history books, but in the collective memory of those who suffered under it.
Want to Explore More of Ireland’s Forgotten Estates?
- Ireland’s Ancient East: Where Myths, Legends, and History Collide
- Hidden Gems of Ireland’s Ancient East You Need to Visit
- Slane Village: The Jewel in Ireland’s Ancient East
Final Thought
Ireland remembers. No amount of time, wealth, or stone mansions can erase the scars left by landlords like the Shirleys. Their legacy is not one of glory, but of warning—a reminder that land is not power when the people who live on it refuse to be broken.
About the Author
