By:

Imagine taking a simple DNA test and discovering that you’re connected to one of the most legendary—and misunderstood—figures in American urban history. That’s exactly what happened to Cindy O’Gara, a Chicago woman whose quest to uncover her Irish ancestry led her straight to Catherine O’Leary, the Irish immigrant historically (and controversially) linked to the Great Chicago Fire of 1871.

But this isn’t just a story about a famous fire—it’s a testament to the power of Irish genealogy, DNA testing, and the enduring bond between Ireland and its far-reaching diaspora. If you’re curious about your own roots, this story might be the nudge you need to begin your journey.

🔬 A DNA Test Unveils the Truth: “I’m an O’Leary!”

Cindy O’Gara had always been curious about her family tree, especially after learning she was adopted. She turned to a popular Ancestry DNA Ireland test kit, hoping for clarity. What she discovered was stunning: her biological father was the great-grandson of Mary O’Leary Scully, Catherine O’Leary’s eldest child.

This revelation connected Cindy to one of the most infamous surnames in Chicago history, and unearthed a story of emigration, resilience, and a long-misunderstood Irish-American legacy.

Interested in starting your own journey? Check out our Ultimate Guide to Tracing Irish Roots in 2025.

🧬 The Power of Genetic Genealogy in Ireland and Beyond

In recent years, tools like Ancestry, MyHeritage, and 23andMe have made it easier than ever to explore your Irish family history. DNA kits offer insights into genetic lineage, geographic origin, and can even connect you to living relatives.

For Irish Americans like Cindy, these tools help piece together the gaps left by emigration, war, and poverty. Tracing ancestors in Ireland can be a challenge, especially due to lost records and the Anglicization of names—but technology is turning the tide.

Get started with trace your Irish ancestry – a comprehensive guide and how to trace your Irish ancestry in 2025.

🌍 From County Kerry to Chicago: The O’Leary Story

Catherine O’Leary was born in Ireland, likely in County Cork, and married Patrick O’Leary, a man from County Kerry. Like many Irish couples fleeing famine, hardship, and limited opportunity, the O’Learys immigrated to America during the mid-19th century.

Patrick fought in the American Civil War, and the couple eventually settled in Chicago. There, they raised a family in a working-class Irish neighborhood on DeKoven Street.

Their story is far from unique. Over 4.5 million Irish emigrated between 1820 and 1930—many of whom settled in Boston, New York, and Chicago. Explore more about emigration and Irish roots in Tracing Your Irish Ancestry – The Murphy Clan and our in-depth look at the Brennan Clan.

🔥 The Great Chicago Fire: Fact, Folklore, and Family

The most enduring myth surrounding Catherine O’Leary is that her cow kicked over a lantern, starting the fire that burned down a large portion of Chicago on October 8, 1871. The narrative stuck for over a century, even though later investigations disproved her involvement.

For Cindy O’Gara, discovering her link to the O’Learys wasn’t just about genealogy—it was about reclaiming a family’s honor.

“I feel like I’ve been handed a legacy,” Cindy said. “Not just of hardship, but of survival. Of being Irish. Of being a woman wronged by history.”

🗺️ How You Can Start Tracing Your Irish Ancestry

Inspired by Cindy’s story? You can begin tracing your family tree in Ireland for free using trusted resources like:

IrishGenealogy.ie – Search Irish civil records, birth, marriage, and death certificates
RootsIreland.ie – Extensive Irish parish records (Note: not completely free, but has a powerful Irish genealogy search tool)
FamilySearch.org – A free global genealogy site perfect for Irish ancestry search
FindMyPast.ie – Offers specialized Irish genealogy records online, including census and military service info
Ancestry.ie – A paid platform, but useful if you’re using DNA + documents

Check out Free Civil Records Ireland and this guide to Irish genealogy civil records to access powerful free tools.

🧭 Planning Your Ancestral Trip to Ireland

Cindy now dreams of visiting County Kerry, walking the same streets her great-great-grandparents once did. You can do the same.

Whether you’re researching the O’Learys, Murphys, Brennans, or another Irish surname, there are endless ways to enrich your ancestry trip:

Visit Glasnevin Cemetery in Dublin
Research your roots at the National Library of Ireland
Explore parish archives in your ancestor’s home county
Use SecretIreland.ie’s ancestry travel guide to build your route

Our full guide to planning the ultimate Irish ancestry trip walks you through every step, from flights to family reunions.

🤝 Reconnecting With Living Relatives

Through her DNA results, Cindy was able to track down her biological father’s sisters, both still living in Illinois. They shared family photos, heirlooms, and vivid oral stories passed down from the O’Learys.

Don’t underestimate the power of genealogy to bring people together. Many who start researching their ancestry end up discovering cousins they never knew existed.

Explore real-life reunion stories and expert tips in our piece on How to Trace Your Irish Ancestry in 2025.

🧾 Final Thoughts: Your Irish Story Is Waiting

From Catherine O’Leary’s unjust blame to Cindy’s heartfelt discovery, this is more than history—it’s living heritage. The tools and technology we have in 2025 allow anyone to become their family’s historian.

And who knows? Maybe your family tree search will uncover a rebel, a poet, or a legend.

Start with the best:
👉 Genealogy Ireland: Your Ultimate Guide to Tracing Irish Roots in 2025
👉 Trace Your Irish Ancestry – A Comprehensive Guide
👉 Uncover Your Irish Roots

And remember—every Irish story begins with a name. Maybe yours.